4/20/2023 0 Comments Hannity tick tock tick tock today![]() ![]() Murphy countered that Dobbs’ statements about Dominion and its alleged election rigging amounted to “protected opinions” and the average viewer understood that from the context of his shows. “There seems to be a Dobbs problem,” the judge said. “It was a true statement to say the allegations had been made.”ĭavis said emails and tweets from ex-Fox host Lou Dobbs - uncovered by Dominion in pre-trial information exchanges in the case - weren’t helpful to Fox’s argument that Dominion wasn’t defamed. “Fox didn’t make the allegation up,” Murphy noted. She said hosts including Maria Bartiromo repeatedly pushed Powell and ex-New York Mayor Rudy Giuliani to provide evidence of their claims the manufacturer rigged the outcome. The network is also asking Davis for summary judgment, arguing that Dominion’s theory that newsworthiness didn’t justify publication of allegations that turned out to be false would have a chilling effect on US journalism.Įrin Murphy, one of Fox’s lawyers, zeroed in on idea the network did nothing wrong by focusing on what she called newsworthy allegations by Trump and his allies about Dominion’s role in the election. “The chances he’s going to take it away from a jury three weeks before trial are pretty slim.”įox’s legal team contends the network was simply reporting issues tied to a story of national importance and that its actions are protected free speech under the First Amendment. “This case has been going on for about two years and the judge has had lots of opportunities to make a case-decisive ruling,” Elson said in an interview. ![]() The internal communications cited by Dominion have led some legal experts to suggest it could be the rare defamation case resulting in summary judgment against the defendant.īut Charles Elson, a lawyer and retired University of Delaware professor, said it was extremely unlikely that Davis would decide the case on summary judgment and rule from the bench. Tuesday’s hearing is for Davis to decide whether he should decide the case without the trial scheduled for April 17. And the lies caused “real harm” to Dominion in the form of lost sales, he added. “We have - in their own words - evidence they knew the theories were false and they just continued to recklessly ignore the truth” to pander to hard-right viewers, Nelson said. “Our good people are going to believe them,” the host added. ![]() Powell’s claims are “obviously untrue” and “unbelievably offensive,” Carlson wrote in emails shown in court. Justin Nelson, one of the voting machine maker’s lawyers, on Tuesday projected several internal communications on a courtroom screen to argue before Delaware Superior Court Judge Eric Davis that key players at Fox never believed the fraud allegations but sat on their hands while Sidney Powell and other allies of then-President Donald Trump went on air to accuse Dominion of conspiring with Democrats and foreign governments to rig the vote. (Bloomberg) - Emails and texts by Tucker Carlson, other Fox News hosts and executives were shown to the judge overseeing Dominion Voting Systems’s $1.6 billion defamation suit against the network for broadcasting 2020 election-fraud claims. ![]()
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |